Grill Thermometers: Testing and Replacing Them
The dial on the lid is telling you the temperature up by the lid. Your steak is a lot closer to the fire.
Told by Ron Garrity · Who's Ron? · Updated October 27, 2026
A grill lid thermometer usually lasts about 3 to 5 years before heat, weather and grease make it drift, sometimes by 25 to 50 degrees or more. It also measures the air near the top of the lid, which can be very different from the temperature at the cooking grate. Test it by holding the stem in boiling water: it should read 212°F at sea level, or about 207°F around Boise and the Treasure Valley, where water boils lower. If it's off and has a calibration nut, adjust it; if not, replace it for about $10 to $25, and use a probe or instant-read thermometer for the food.
- Lifespan
- 3-5 years
- Boils at sea level
- 212°F
- Treasure Valley
- ~207°F
- Replacement
- $10-$25
The boiling water test
- 1Pull the thermometer out of the lid (most are held by a nut or a clip on the inside).
- 2Bring a pot of water to a full rolling boil.
- 3Hold the stem in the water, at least 2 inches deep, without touching the pot. Wait about 30 seconds.
- 4Compare to the boiling point where you live: 212°F at sea level, about 1°F lower for every 500 feet of elevation. Around 2,700 feet in Boise, that's roughly 207°F.
- 5If it's more than a few degrees off, recalibrate or replace it.
Lid thermometer or a probe?
Lid thermometer
- •Tells you roughly how hot the grill is
- •Reads air near the lid, often cooler or hotter than the grate
- •Good enough for preheating
Probe or instant-read
- •Tells you how hot the food is, which is what matters
- •Leave-in probes with a wire or wireless base for long cooks
- •An instant-read for steaks, burgers and chicken
Use the lid to know the grill is hot. Use a probe to know dinner is done.
Grill pages
Ribs at 300, supposedly
I did a rack of ribs one summer, low and slow, keeping the lid thermometer right on 300 like the recipe said. Three hours later they were tough and dried out, like jerky with a bone in it. I couldn't figure out what I'd done wrong.
So I took the thermometer out and put it in a pot of boiling water on the stove. It read 170. Water boils at about 207 out here. It was reading almost 40 degrees low, which meant my "300" had really been closer to 340. Those ribs never had a chance. New thermometer, plus a probe for the meat, and the next rack fell off the bone. My wife said the first batch was fine. She's being nice. They were not fine.
Part of
More for the yard
Lifespans and costs are averages. Yours will vary with brand, use, climate and upkeep. When a page says call a pro, call a pro.